The Christmas Star: Astronomical phenomenon or legend?

One of the most important symbols of Christmas is the Christmas star. Its appearance symbolizes the beginning of the celebration in the evening sky on December 24. It is from the moment the first star rises that most Ukrainians sit down to the festive table.

The Bible story of the star

According to the Bible, the three wise men saw a star in the east that showed them the way to the birthplace of Jesus Christ. This image is deeply imprinted in the Christian tradition, although the text of the Holy Scripture itself does not provide an exact description of the phenomenon.

Jean Fouquet’s painting “Adoration of the Magi” (16th century) depicts a Bible scene. In the upper right corner, we see a bright star, which is usually associated with the Star of Bethlehem, which led the wise men to Jesus. Interestingly, the artist has depicted a castle and soldiers in the background, which may be an allusion to an actual historical event, the Battle of Castillon, which took place in 1453.
Source: Wikipedia

For example, the words “the star…stopped over the place where the Child was” indicate that this may not have been so much an astronomical phenomenon as a manifestation of God’s power.

For centuries, scientists and historians have been trying to find an explanation for what the Star of Bethlehem could symbolize-whether it was a nova, a comet, or a rare conjunction of planets.

The symbolism of the star in holiday traditions

The Christmas star has become one of the main attributes of the holidays. It decorates the top of the Christmas tree and is a central element in the traditions of carolers. During the Christmas holidays in Ukraine, carolers wear a large eight-pointed star to symbolize the birth of the Savior.

The postal issue “New Joy has become”, which Ukrposhta created for Christmas 2024. The stamp depicts a vytynanka telling about the traditions of the holiday: girls with the Star of Bethlehem sing carols, the Magi carry gifts, from house to house the mourners “lead the Goat”, and Ukrainian soldiers defend our freedom, our holidays and customs. Source: Ukrposhta

These traditions differ from region to region. For example, in the village of Kryvorivnia in the Hutsul region, only men carol, and this tradition is still in place today.

Was the Star of Bethlehem an astronomical phenomenon?

The biblical texts do not describe exactly what the Star of Bethlehem was. However, scholars offer several hypotheses:

  1. Nova or supernova

      From time to time, star-like objects appear in the sky that significantly increase their luminosity. In ancient times, such phenomena were called novae or supernovae.

      Supernova 1987A, detected by the Hubble Space Telescope in 2017. Source: NASA, ESA; R. Kirshner, and M. Mutchler; R. Avila

      It is known that on February 23, 4 BC, a bright “extra” star appeared in the constellation of Aquila, which could have attracted the attention of the Magi. Later, in the twentieth century, astronomers discovered a double pulsar (now known as the Hulse-Taylor pulsar) at approximately this location, which could have been formed as a result of a supernova explosion. However, current estimates suggest that its brilliance was unlikely to have been so bright as to arouse significant interest.

      1. Comet

      Bright comets with long tails have always attracted people’s attention. For example, Halley’s Comet, which approached Earth in 12 BC, could have been a source of inspiration for the Bible story.

      One notable example is Giotto di Bondone’s fresco The Adoration of the Magi (1267-1337), inspired by Halley’s Comet, which the artist observed in 1301. Source: Wikipedia

      Another possible explanation is the mysterious comet mentioned in Chinese and Korean chronicles of 5 BC. It was observed for three months and appeared in the morning in the east, which corresponds to the description from the Bible.

      1. Conjunction of bright planets

      A unique phenomenon took place on June 17, 2 BC: Jupiter and Venus merged into one bright spot in the sky. However, this event took place in the West, not in the East, so it does not quite match the Bible’s description.

      The grand conjunction of Jupiter and Saturn in December 2020. Source: Pete Lawrence

      In 1614, Johannes Kepler calculated that 7 years before Christ, Jupiter and Saturn formed a conjunction, which could be interpreted by astrologers as a sign of the birth of a king. Perhaps the Magi interpreted this event as a harbinger of the birth of Jesus.

      The Christmas star is more than just a celestial body. It represents hope and faith. Whether or not you see it in the sky, it shines in the hearts of everyone who celebrates Christmas. Happy holidays!

      Advertising